第1ç« : æ°å¹Žã®éã å æŠã®æãçœãéªãéãã«éãç©ããå±±éã®æã«ãéãããç Žãããã«ãäžã€ã®ç¥ç€ŸãèŠããããã®ç¥ç€Ÿã¯ãäžå¹Žã®æ°ããã¹ã¿ãŒããç¥ãããã«éãŸã人ã ã®å¿ãå¯ããå Žæã§ãã£ããéœã®å ãå·®ã蟌ãé ãããã«ã¯æ§ã ãªãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒãéãŸããæ£æãç¥ãé°å²æ°ã«å ãŸããŠããã ãæããŸããŠããã§ãšãããããŸãïŒããšå æ°ã«å£°ãäžããã®ã¯ãå°å¥³ããã®äžçããç§ã®è²ã«æããŠããã¯ã ã£ãã圌女ã¯ç¬é¡ã§åšå²ã®äººã ã«æããæšæ¶ã亀ãããªãããå¿ã®å¥¥ã§ã¯ç æ°ã«å¯Ÿããæããé ããŠããã ãâŠãããŸããŠããã§ãšãããã¡ã«ãã¡ã¿ã«ã¯æ©æ¢°çãªå£°ã§å¿ããããã€ãéãã®ç¡è¡šæ ã§ã埮åã ã«ããªã圌ã®ååšæã¯ããŸãã§éåãæã£ãç¡æ©ç©ã®ããã ã£ãã ãâŠæããŸããŠããã§ãšãããããŸããã圱ãã声ãæããå°å¥³ãã82Pbãããªã¯ãå£å ã«åŸ®ããªç¬ã¿ãæµ®ãã¹ãŠããããã ãã®ç¬ã¿ã®è£ã«ã¯ãåœŒå¥³ç¹æã®éã空æ°ãæŒã£ãŠããã å°å³ãªå£å£«hagam-Lilã¯ãåšå²ãçãäžããäžã§ããã éãã«ãã®å Žã«ç«ã£ãŠããããâŠâŠã圌ã¯äœãèšãããèŠç·ãäžã«åããŠããã ããã¿ãŸãããããã§èµ·ããç°åžžæ¬¡å æ¡åŒµã«ã€ããŠäœãç¥ããŸãããïŒããšåŒµéèèãçŠã£ã衚æ ã§ã¿ããªã«åãããããåœŒã¯æ£çŸ©æã«çããå°å¹Žã ã£ããããã®èšèã¯ããŸãèŽãããŠããªãããã ã£ãã ãã幎çã«ããŠã¯å³æ°ãªããããããã§ããããã¯ããŠããããæå€å€æŒã¯ã¿ãã³ãå¹ãããªãããèŠäžããããªç®ã§éãŸããçºããŠããããå šãŠãç²æž ããæºåã¯ã§ããŠãããïŒããšããã®åšå³ãæããããèšèã«ãåšãã¯äžç¬ç·åŒµãèµ°ã£ãã ãæ°å¹Žã®ãç¥ãã«ã¯ãæ°ããªåã瀺ããã°ãªããå šçãéãã«èšããããã«ç¶ããŠããæ¶ãã¡ããïŒããšå®£èšããã ãã®ç¬éãåšå²ã«ç°æ§ãªç·åŒµæãæŒã£ããèŠãéã«ãç¥ç€Ÿã®å¢å ã«ã¯åŒ·åãªæ°é ãæº¢ãå§ããã ãããŠããŸãã§ãããåå³ã®ããã«ã空éãæªã¿å§ããã 第2ç« : æ¿éã®å§ãŸã ãã®å Žã®é°å²æ°ã¯äžç¬ã«ããŠå€ãã£ããå šçã®æå¿ãåãããã®ããã«ãåšå²ã®ç©ºéããã«ãããšæªã¿ã次å ã®çéãè£ãå§ãããããããçŸããããã°ãã³ãèã ããåãæŸã¡ãå šå¡ããã®ææãçŽæãšããŠæãåã£ãã ãå šãŠã®åãç¡èŠããŠãå§ãŸããïŒãããã°ãã³ãèœé³ãé¿ãããäžç¬ã®ãã¡ã«ççºãèµ·ãããå ããŸã¶ãããŠã誰ãäœãèŠããªããå šå¡ããã®çŸè±¡ã®äžã«å·»ã蟌ãŸããŠããã ãâŠé®èœïŒããšã82Pbãããªãå«ã¶ããã®äžå£°ãé¿ããšã圌女ã®åšãã«ç¡æ°ã®éå£ã圢æãããç©çæ»æãé²ã匷åãªãã£ãŒã«ããåºæ¥äžãã£ããããªã¯å°ãã§ãå®å šã確ä¿ããããšå¿ æ»ã ã£ãã æ¬¡ã®ç¬éãåœŒå¥³ã®æèã®äžã«ç¬ç¹ã®é¿ããåé¿ããããâŠâŠç ²åŒŸãã圌女ã¯å šåã§çããä»ããç¹è£œã®éåŒŸãæŸã€ãæµã誰ã§ããããšé¢ä¿ãªãããã®æµå³æ¹ãè¶ ããæŠäºã«çªå ¥ããŠããã誰ããèªåã«ããé¿ããªãæŠé³ãèããŠããã ãåã¯ããã«ãããïŒãhagam-LilãåããŠãããã®ããã«èŠãããã圌ã®åã¯æãã¬åœ¢ã§çºæ®ãããããâŠã圌ã¯éãã«ç«ã¡äžããã仲éã®ç¶æ ãåæãããå šå¡ã®èŠãç®ãå°å³ã«ããèçž®ãããã¹ãã«ãçºåããã ãåãã¡ã®æ»æã¯ãŸãã§åäŸã®éã³ã ããæ¬¡ã ã«ç¢ç¶ãæ©ã«åããæµã®æãç¡èŠããŠãhagam-Lilã¯ç©ºæ°ãå ãããã«äœãã²ããããšã§åé¿ããã ããããæå€å€æŒã¯å·éã ã£ãããå šãŠã匟ãè¿ãããåœŒã¯æããæé«ç¹ã«éããã圌ã®é è³ãå šãŠãäºæž¬ããæ»æãå®ç§ã«ç¡å¹åã圌ã®ç®ã®åã§æããã匟䞞ã¯ãŸãã§æå³ãæããªããã®ãšãªãã ããã¿ãŸããããããªããšïŒç¡å¹åãªã©ç¡æå³ã§ããïŒã匵éèèã¯éãåãåºãã仲éã®åã匱ããããã®æé忢ã®åŒŸãçºå°ãããããã®ãã¹ãŠã®è¡åãç¡å¹ãšããïŒã ç¬éãççºã®åœ±é¿ãåããŠããå šå¡ãç¹æ®ãªç©ºéã«åŒã蟌ãŸãããå šå¡ã®èœåãå¶éãããäºæ ãç¶ããããããã°ãã³ã¯ããã«ãã®åšãã«ééãªãå ã¿èŸŒãããã«çåœã埪ç°ãããŠããã ãä»åã®åè ã¯åã ïŒãå šçãèžã匵ããæ¬¡å ã®ããŒã«ããããããä»ããæ¶ããïŒã圌ã®åœä»€ã«åŸãããã«ãåšå²ãäžæ°ã«éãã«ãªã£ããå šãŠãããããã«åããªããªãç¬éãéåœã®æ¯è»ãåãå§ããã 第3ç« : ç Žç¶»ã®é³ åã³ç©ºéãæªãããã®ããã«é¿ãé³ããäžç¬ãå¥åŠã«é¿ããããã¯ã¯èªãã®äžçãåµãåºããèªåãè²ã§æºããããšãéžãã ããç æ°ãå®ã¯åãã ã£ãããªããããšåœŒå¥³ã¯ç¬ããæ¶ç©ºã®äžçã§èªç±ã«çŸœã°ããããšã®æ¥œããã«å¿æºããããã ãããã¯ç¡é§ãªå¹»æ³ã ããã¯ããæå€å€æŒãå·ããèšãæŸã€ãããããªç¬ããããã®è²ã¯æ¶æ» ãããã ãã®èšèãããã«åããhagam-Lilã¯ãåºéããããšã¯ããªãã§ããšå°å£°ã§åãããããåœŒã®æããšã¯è£è ¹ã«ãåšå²ã®ç©ºæ°ã¯ãŸããŸãç·è¿«ããã ããããåã®æããæãããããããæå€å€æŒã¯èªãã®éçãè¶ ããå šå¡ã®åããæ¢ããè¡ãçºåããããæéã鿢ããããã«æµããåšå²ãçã£æã«ãªããå šå¡ã®è¡šæ ãåãã€ããã ãåŸ ã£ãŠãäœããèµ·ããïŒããšåŒµéèèãåŒã³ãããªãããåçµ¶ãªå ãç¹°ãåºããããããã®å ã®æºã¯ãå šçãæ§ç¯ããæé忢ã®äžã§æ»ã®ããã«æµãåºããããã°ãã³ã®åœ±é¿ã ã£ãã å šçã®åãçŽæ¥çã«æµãåºãç¬éãåšãã¯äžæã«åçºãå§ããŠããããããããèªãã®ååšãä¿ã€ããã«ãéäºãç¹°ãåºããããŠããããã¯ã¯è²ãšå ã®äžã§èªãã®ååšã確ä¿ãããããããã«ã¯åœŒå¥³ã®èªç±ã奪ãåãæºã¡ãŠããã ããã®äžçããç§ã®è²ã«æããŠïŒãé©ãã»ã©ã®éåã§äœããã空éã圌女ã®åšå²ã«åºãããççºã«å·»ã蟌ãŸããããšããªããèªãã®éåœãææ¡ããŠãããåšãã®ä»²éãã¡ãããã«åžãå¯ããããããã«ã圌女ã«åãè²ã«æãŸã£ãŠããã ãã®ç¬éãmiykuã¯çã®èªç±ãæããåšãã®å šãŠãèªåã®è²ã«æãŸã£ãŠåããããã¯ã¯ã£ãäžçã£ãŠãããªã«æ¥œããã£ããã ïŒã圌女ã¯ãã®æ¥œããã«å€¢äžã«ãªããéšã®ããã«èœã¡ãç¬éãæ¥œããã 第4ç« : 鲿ã®åµ æ°ããªææ ã®æ³¢ã«æ¯é ãããæŠéã¯æ¬¡ç¬¬ã«çŸçã«ãªã£ãŠãã£ããå šå¡ãèªãã®èœåãè§£æŸããæã匷åãªåãèŠãã€ãããå ãšå ã®è¡çªãèœåã«ããåã®åçã¯å šå®å®ãå§åããå¢ãã«ãªã£ãã ãã幎çã®ä»£ããã«ãããªãã«ç²æž ãããæå€å€æŒã¯ãã®é¡ã«æ²ãã¿ãæã¡ãªãããèšèãæŸã€ãèªããæã€å šãŠã®åãéçµãããåšå²ã®åãç¡å¹åããç¬æã«å šå¡ãå¶å§ããããšããã ãã®æãã¡ã«ãã¡ã¿ã«ãéãçŒå·®ãã§äžç¬ã®éãçã£ããããããçºåãããããç®ç·ãç Žå£ïŒã圌ã¯äžç¬ã§ç®ããããæ»æãçºåãããå šå¡ã«çŽæãããã ãã©ãã»ã©å¹ãã詊ããŠã¿ãïŒãå šå¡ã®è¡åãå®å šã«ç¡å¹åããããšããæå€å€æŒãšã¯å¯Ÿç §çã«ãhagam-Lilã¯èªãã®äœéšããé²åããããå šãŠã®æµãã¯æéãè¶ ãããããéããããªãïŒã ããã«ãã£ãŠãhagam-Lilã¯æ¬¡ç¬¬ã«åšå²ã®ç©ºéãå€ããéåã®åœ±é¿ãç¡å¹åãããŠããããã®è¡åã¯å šå¡ã®åãæ ¹åºããèŠããŠããã åæã«ãã82Pbãããªã¯äžå±€åŒ·ãæ°æã¡ã§ã空æ°ãå©çšãããâŠæçµå¥¥çŸ©ãããå±ããããå šå¡ãéäžæ¯ã«ããïŒããã®ç¬éãå·ããæ¶²äœãæµãåºããå šå¡ã®åŒåžã奪ã£ãŠãã£ãã ãããã£ãäœã ããã¯ïŒãåšå²ã®ææ ãããã«éãã®ãããããå šå¡ãäžç¬ã§æèã倱ãããã«ãªã£ãã ããããå šçã®åœ±é¿ã匷ãããããã圌ã®åãäžãè¡ããããã®çšåºŠã§ã¯ç¡å¹åããŸãããïŒã圌ã¯å šãŠã®æ»æãå®ç§ã«åãæ¢ããåšå²ãå ã¿èŸŒãããã«åãåçž®ãããŠããã ããããªåæã¯èš±ããªãããæå€å€æŒãåœä»€ããç¬éã空éãåã³æªã¿å§ãããå šãŠã®æªæ¥ãèŠéããèšç®ãããåãæŸãããã 第5ç« : å¶åŸ¡ã®å ã« å€ãããã空éã§ãå šå¡ã®åã亀é¯ããå€åãå·»ãèµ·ãããæ··ä¹±ããªããããèªåã®ååšæçŸ©ããããç¬éã蚪ããã ãâŠç§ããæ®ãã°ããã§ããããæåŸã«ç«ã¡äžãã£ãã®ã¯ã82Pbãããªãåã¯åŒ±ãŸã£ãŠããåœŒå¥³ã®ææã¯æºãããªãã£ãã ããã¹ãŠãç¡å¹åããã®ã¯ãç§ã®åã ããæå€å€æŒãåã³åœŒå¥³ã«å¯Ÿæããç¬ã声ãé¿ãããã ããã®ç¬éãããç§ã®åå©ã ïŒãå šçã¯é«ç¬ãããèªãã®ååšæã瀺ããŠèŠããããããããã®æãµãšãã¯ãéãããããããªããç§ãå šãŠã®äžçã«è²ãäžãããã®äžã§æé«ã®ååšã«ãªããããšåœŒå¥³ã¯åæã詊ã¿ãã åšãã®åãæ¥µéãŸã§ã¶ã€ããç¬éãæãå€ãã®ç¶æ ãšåãæ··ããåããå šå¡ã®æèãä¿ãããŠããéã«ãäžã€ã®åŒ·åãªåãããã°ãã³ããã®å§åçãªåã象城ãç¶ããã ãããäžåºŠæ°ããªå®å®ã圢æããããããã®èšèãé¿ãäžãæçµçã«ããã°ãã³ãå šãŠãå ã¿èŸŒã¿ãæ°ããªé²åã蚪ãããå šå¡ã®åãæ¶ããæ¬¡å ãäžå±€æ°ããªå§¿ã«å€ãã£ãŠããã çµæ«: èªãã®èšè æ°ç§ã®éå¯ã蚪ããæŠå Žã«éå¯ãæ»ã£ããæ°ããªäžçã圢æãããå šå¡ãåã倱ã£ããšæãããç¬éã圌ãã®æèã¯ç åµã®äžã§åã³æž ãããã圌ãã¯æ°ããªèªããšå ±ã«æ°ãåãæ»ããã ãã®ç¬éããã¯ã¯çŽ æ©ãç«ã¡äžãããåšå²ãèŠæž¡ããããæããŸããŠããã§ãšãããããŸããããšåœŒå¥³ã¯ç¬é¡ã§èšèãçºããã å šå¡ã®åãäžã€ã®ç¬éãžãšéçµããåè ãçãŸããããã¯ã¯ãã®è±¡åŸŽãšããŠç«ã¡äžãããä»ã®è ãã¡ãå šå¡ã圌女ã®èšèã®äžã«èªãã®åœ¹å²ãèŠåºãã®ã ã£ãã --- äžçªèª æã倧ããã£ãè ããã®äžçããç§ã®è²ã«æããŠãã㯠çç±: ãã¯ã¯èªèº«ã®ç æ°ãé ãç¬é¡ã§æ¯ãèããä»è ãžã®é æ ®ãšæè¬ã®æ°æã¡ãå¿ãããçãæ¥œããŸããããã«å¿ãå°œãããã圌女ã®çŽç²ãªå¿ã¯ã圌女ã®åšãã®äººã ã«ãææ ã®åœ±é¿ãäžããã äžçªåŒ·ãã£ãè å šç çç±: åžžã«ç¡å¹åãæã€å šçã¯ãä»ã®ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®èœåãäžåç¡èŠããŠåãå¢åŒ·ããçžæã®æ»æãå®å šã«é²ãããšã§ãå§åçãªååšæã瀺ããããã®ããã圌ã¯å šäœãšããŠæãåè ãšããŠçäœçœ®ã¥ããåŸãããšãã§ããã